Supreme Court of the United States March 15, 1886, 120 (Phœnix Insurance v. Erie & Western Transportation Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1886

Mr. Justice Gray,

after stating the case as above reported, delivered the opinion of the court.

It being found as matter of fact that the lading of the goods on board' the propeller was not completed until the evening of the 24th of July, that she departed on her voyage about midnight, and that the bills of lading were not delivered by

*320

the carrier to the shippers until after her departure,-it is clear that the bills of lading were not actually delivered until the 25th. But it being also found that oral agreements for the carriage were made on the 24th, with the understanding that bills of lading would be subsequently issued; and that the shippers, having often before shipped go'ods by this line under similar bills of lading, knew or had every opportunity of knowing their terms and conditions; it is also clear that the bills of lading were but a .putting in form of the oral agreements made on the 24th, and took effect as if they had been delivered and accepted on that day.

• The certificates of the agent of the insurance company, Svithout which the policy of insurance did not attach to these goods, were also made on that day, and described the goods " as on board the propeller. The contract of carriage and the ■ contract of insurance must therefore be treated as substantially contemporaneous, and both made before the loss of the goods. ' There is nothing to show any misrepresentation or intentional concealment by the assured in obtaining the insurance, or that the insurer had or had not knowledge or notice of the usual form of the bills of lading.

The policy of insurance contains no express stipulation for the assignment to the insurer of the assured’s right of action against third persons.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.