New York Supreme Court March 15, 1887 (Dunham v. Townshend)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-03-1887

Daniels, J.:

The plaintiff, claiming to be the owner of an undivided half, brought this action to recover the possession, of that part of five lots of land of twenty-five feet front each situated on the southerly side of Ninety-ninth street, 100 feet westerly of Second avenue, in the city of New York. Before, and at the time when the action was commenced, the other defendants were in the occupancy and possession of the property as lessees or assignees of the defendant, John Townshend. Possession of the property was demanded from the defendants before the commencement of the action, but it was not surrendered to the plaintiff. The defendant, John Townshend, defended the action, but he did not, by his answer, claim to be the owner of any interest in the property. It did appear that he had taken two deeds from other parties for an undivided one-sixth of the property, but it was not shown that either of the grantors in the deeds ever acquired or owned any interest in the land, or had any title whatever to convey to this defendant, and for that reason these deeds had no special operative effect by way of defense in the action.

The real defense which was made was that the plaintiff was not the owner of the interest claimed by her in the property, but that it was owned either by the city of New York, as land between high and low-water mark, or by a general assignee for the benefit of creditors, or a receiver appointed by the Court of Chancery. To support the allegation of title in the city, evidence was given on *582behalf of the defendants tending to prove the fact to be that the land was overflowed by the ordinary full tides. This was denied by the plaintiff, whose testimony tended to prove the contrary, and that the land, with the exception of certain creek bottoms in it, was above the ordinary full tide.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.