New York Supreme Court April 15, 1887 (Murphy v. New York Central & Hudson River Railroad)

Hardin, P. J.:

In the course of his charge to .the jury, the learned judge said, viz.: “ The main question, as it seems to me in this case, upon the subject of negligence of the defendant, arises upon the proposition as to whether or not the employees of the defendant did something to the car that came down upon the ear or cars at which the plaintiff was at work and produced the collision, and