New York Supreme Court October 15, 1887 (Burdick v. Freeman)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-10-1887
Haight, J.:
This action was brought to recover damages for enticing away the plaintiffs wife and for harboring and debauching her. At the conclusion of the evidence the defendant asked the court to charge that the plaintiff eannot maintain this action in the courts of this State. The request was refused and exception taken.
It appears that the plaintiff and defendant are, and for many years have been, residents of the village of Smethport, in the State of Pennsylvania, and that that place is the county seat of McKean county, and that none of the acts complained of on this trial were committed within the State of New York. The complaint does allege that the defendant debauched and carnally knew the plaintiff’s wife, at the village of Niagara Falls, on the 7th day of January, 1885. It was claimed that they went there together and staid over night at the Spencer House, occupying the same room, and that they registered as Robert I). Crawford and wife, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. It toned out, however, that Robert I). Crawford and wife, of Philadelphia, were there in person and occupied the room taken on the night in question; and the plaintiff, upon the trial of this action, admitted that he was mistaken in reference to that claim. The defendant was a physician and a graduate of the Buffalo Medical University. At the time this action was commenced he was temporarily in the city of Buffalo attending'the commencement exercises of the university, and was in the act of talcing the cars on his return home when he was arrested upon an ordei, issued in this action. It is urged that the courts of this State should not retain jurisdiction of an action of this. character when all the parties reside in another State, and when none of the acts relied upon occurred in this State.
In the case of Gardner v. Thomas (14 Johns., 134) the action was for an assault and battery committed on the high seas on board of a British vessel, both parties being British subjects.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit