Supreme Court of Alabama December 15, 1887 (Thompson v. Hartline)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1887

STONE, C. J.

One of the objections urged in this case is, that the order removing Thompson from the guardianship, being made out of term time, and at a time to which there had been no adjournment from a regular term, is invalid. Boynton v. Nelson, 46 Ala. 501, and Childress v. Childress, 49 Ala. 237, are relied on in support of this view. The order in this case was not appealed from, and hence the question comes up collaterally in the present proceeding. To avail anything, presented as it is, it must be on the ground that the order was void, that Thompson is still guardian, and hence he could not be brought to a settlement.

On the day on which the citation required Thompson to appear and file his account-current and vouchers for a settlement, he appeared by himself and counsel. He objected to being brought to a settlement, but not on the ground that he had not been legally removed from the guardianship. His exact objection is in the following language:

“ Comes the movent, E. M. Thompson, and moves to strike the citation issued by the court 20th July, 1886, and demurs to the same, because court can not, on an order removing guardian, also order guardian to file acct. (account) and vouchers for final settlement.”

The motion and demurrer being overruled, the guardian thereupon filed his account current, on which the settlement was had. Objecting on one ground — the joinder of two *67orders in one — was a waiver of all others. — Floyd v. State, 82 Ala. 16; Garrett v. Trabue, Ib. 227; Co. Comm’rs v. Woodstock Iron Co. Ib. 151; Jaques v. Horton, 76 Ala. 238; 3 Brick. Dig. 444, § 574. There was no error in making both orders at one and the same time, nor in embracing them in one and the same entry. The motion and demurrer as made were properly overruled.

In one respect, however, the Probate Court erred. The witnesses, J. A. 'Death and Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.