Appellate Court of Illinois May 27, 1887 (Totel v. Bonnefoy)
Also known as
United States · · · 27-05-1887
Welch, J.
The plaintiff in error filed 1ns hill of complaint in the Circuit Court to prevent defendants in error from damming up a certain ditch or drain at the point it left plaintiff in error’s premises. Defendants in error had filled up the ditch, and plaintiff in error removed the obstructions, and filed this bill to enjoin the defendants in error from again filling it up. Plaintiff in error alleged in his bill that for more than twenty years prior to the filing of his bill, the surface water from the S. W. £ of 17, continuously drained north in a ditch through the center of the 17. W. J. He also alleges that this is the natural course of the water. He also alleges in the amendment to his bill that the owners-of the land, by mutual agreement, reconstructed the ditch afterward obstructed, and that Bonnefoy bought with full knowledge of the fact. Temporary injunction granted. Joint answer of defendants in error filed. It admits that the S. W. ¿ is wet, but denies that the natural course of the water is north along the line dividing the E. and W. of the 17. W. J, and alleges that the natural course is northeast and cuts off the southeast corner of the 17. W. J. It denies the making of the ditch in 1881, and the acquiescence of the owner; and alleges that m 1877 plaintiff in error fraudulently induced Carpenter to consent to the excavation of the ditch by representing that it would be of benefit to him; that thereupon plaintiff in error made a system of drains upon his own land, which brought the water upon the defendants in increased quantities and with greater speed, and so rendered worthless large tracts of their land; .that the ditch did not exist prior to 1877; and that the defendants dammed the ditch in March, 1882, to protect themselves. On the hearing the court dissolved the injunction and dismissed the bill, and complainant sued out this writ of error.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit