Supreme Court of Iowa March 21, 1887 (Gardner v. Lightfoot)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-03-1887

Seevers, J.

1. Contract: undue influence: relations of trust: setting aside. I. We have read the evidence with great care, and fail to find any which tends to show that the defendant obtained the. conveyance, by undue influence, or that he made any fraudulent representations whatever, and thereby obtained such conveyance. The evidence fails to show that the defendant even asked foi; such conveyance, or that it was made in consequence of any representations made by him. On the contrary, the evidence shows that the plaintiff and her husband executed it on their own motion; and, if the fact is otherwise, the plaintiff has wholly failed to introduce any evidence so showing. It will be conceded that the rule is that when persons who sustain relations of trust and confidence enter into a contract, and the stronger obtains an advantage over the weaker rnincl, the same will be set aside, unless the beneficiary shows the contract to have been fairly obtained. Spargur v. Hall, 62 Iowa, 198. But there must be something done by the stronger to influence the weaker mind. If the former is passive, it cannot be said that there is either undue influence or fraud. Now, in the present case, we assert with confidence that the evidence fails to show that the defendant did anything to obtain the conveyance, unless it was his agreement to execute the lease for life, and this he did, and his promise to provide and care for the plaintiff and her husband. As to the latter, as we read the evidence, the defendant simply agreed to the proposition as made by the plaintiff and her husband. They fixed the terms and conditions of the contract upon which the conveyance was made. The defendant did not even make a suggestion in relation thereto! It is impossible, therefore, to say that the conveyance was obtained fraudulently, or by *580undue influence, or that the contract was not entered into by the defendant in good faith. . i

2. Conveyance; consideration: parol to vary writing. 3.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.