New Jersey Court of Chancery May 15, 1887 (Dickerson v. Hodges)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-05-1887
Van Fleet, V. C.
This is a foreclosure suit. The bill was filed January 21st, 1887. John F. Hawkins was made a defendant, because in April, 1885, he procured a writ of attachment to be issued out of the Monmouth county common pleas against the owner of the equity of. redemption of the mortgaged premises, under which her interest therein was attached. Mr. Hawkins has answered, admitting the issuing of the attachment and the seizure made under it, but says, that the debt on which the attachment was founded, was paid on the 29th of June, 1886, and the suit discontinued. Mr. Hawkins also files a disclaimer, disclaiming all right, title and interest, legal and equitable, of, in and to the mortgaged premises, and every part thereof, and asks that the bill, as to him, be dismissed, with costs. His disclaimer is signed by his solicitor, but not by counsel, nor by himself in person, nor is it under oath.
The complainant moves, under paragraph 224 of the rules, to strike out the disclaimer on three grounds : first, because it is not signed by counsel; second, because it is not under oath; and third, because it is not signed by the defendant in person, and *46attested by a person competent to be a witness. The rule upon this subject, as given in Smith’s Practice, is as follows: “ A disclaimer, being accompanied with an answer, is put in upon oath. It must also be signed by the defendant, and in no case can such signature be waived with propriety, since no record will be received without signature, which tends- to the prejudice of the rights of the defendant.” 1 Smith’s Ch. Pr. 175. Mr. Barbour states the rule in substantially the same words. 1 Barb. Oh. Pr.-171. And Mr. Daniell says, the court may give a defendant leave to file a disclaimer without oath, but not without signature, and that when a disclaimer is filed without oath, the defendant’s signature should be attested by some person competent to be a witness. He also says, that it must be signed by counsel. 1 Dan. Ch.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit