Michigan Supreme Court February 10, 1887 (Sweet v. Swift)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-02-1887
Campbell, C. J.
Plaintiff, who is a transferee not holding any better title than his assignor, sued defendant on two alleged acceptances.
One A. E. Jackson, on March 1 and March 12, 1879, received from Matthias Kundinger two orders, payable to Jackson or bearer, for $35,14 and 816.12, addressed to Swift- & Lockwood, a firm of which defend ant was a member. They had an outstanding contract with Kundinger for the delivery of logs, which Kundinger had not performed. Jackson presented these orders, which were payable on demand, several times to Mr. Lockwood, who refused to honor them. In-June, 1879, Swift & Lockwood dissolved, and Swift assumed the business and liabilities. On the eighteenth of December 1879, Jackson induced one Nor val Cameron, an agent of defendant, to write an acceptance upon them, with the understanding that they should only be payable if Kundinger had any credits at any time to cover them, which he never had. Jackson kept them for awhile, and Cameron would not pay them. He subsequently turned them over to Mr. Sweet, the-plaintiff.
The plaintiff insisted below, and insists here, that he and his assignor, Mr. Jackson, were bona fide holders of this paper, and that the, acceptance could not be affected by testimony of the circumstances and conditions under which it was given. The jury found for defendant. We have no doubt the verdict was warranted.
These orders, which in form were bills of exchange payable to bearer on demand, were given to Jackson in the first place, and held by him until transferred to Sweet. They were not subject to acceptance, and a demand could only be made for payment. This could not be done indefinitely, and, when payment was refused, they ceased to be binding on the drawer as negotiable paper, unless he was notified of the dishonor. No such notice was given, and the paper was thenceforth valueless in itself.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit