New York Supreme Court November 15, 1887 (Edwards v. Schoharie County National Bank)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1887
Potter, J.
This is an appeal from a judgment entered upon the report of a referee, determining that a certain bond and mortgage set forth in the complaint belonged to the plaintiff (respondent), and not to the defendant (appellant) bank or its receiver, and should be transferred by the receiver to the plaintiff.
That, determination depends primarily upon the legal or equitable relation between the plaintiff^ and defendant Krum; and, secondarily, upon the relation between the defendant Krum and the defendant Lamont, the receiver of *254the bank, in respect of the mortgage and bond. The bond and mortgage are not payable to the plaintiff in terms, nor have they ever been delivered to or possessed by the plaintiff. They were, in terms, made payable to defendant Krum, and were by him transferred and delivered to the defendant bank before the commencement of this action. Nevertheless, the plaintiff has brought this action to establish that : she was at the time of the execution and delivery of the bond and mortgage to Krum and by him to the defendant bank, and ever since, has been the equitable owner of the bond and mortgage, and that she is entitled to the posses- . sion of the same and the right to control and enforce the same for her own benefit.
Upon the trial the plaintiff produced evidence virtually undisputed, from which the referee has found these well sustained conclusions, viz.: That plaintiff, pursuant to an . agreement made in March, 1884, between her and defendant Krum for that,purpose, furnished $6,000, with which Krum was to pay for a certain farm about to be sold, and that the plaintiff should have a mortgage upon such farm to secure the payment of the moneys so furnished by plaintiff to pay for the farm; that the money was accordingly furnished on or about the first day of April thereafter by the plaintiff to the defendant Krum upon his requisition therefor and statement that he had.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit