Supreme Court of the United States December 5, 1887 (Chapman v. Goodnow's Administrator)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1887

Mr. Chief Justice Waite

delivered the opinion of the court.

These are writs of error for the review of two judgments of the Supreme Court of Iowa — one against Richard B. Chapman, and the other against John Stryker — in suits brought by Edward K. Goodnow, assignee of the Iowa Homestead Company, in his lifetime, to recover money paid by the Homestead Company for taxes levied by the county of Webster on “Dos Monies River lands” belonging to Chapman and Stryker, respectively, for the years 1864 to 1811, both inclusive. For a statement of the general facts on which the right of recovery

*542

depends reference is made to the case of

Stryker

v. Crane, ante, 527. The Homestead Company assigned its claims against these owfaers after the decree in the suit of

Homestead Company

v.

Valley

Railroad, 17 Wall. 153, was rendered.

The suits were begun August 5, 1876, and in each case a demurrer was filed to the original petition January 19,1877. On the 12th of February, 1879, the county of Webster appeared in each of the suits and filed a petition therein setting forth “ that the taxes mentioned in said petition [that of Goodnow] were duly and legally assessed and levied by said county upon the lands therein mentioned, at the times, for the years and amounts, and in the manner and form alleged and set forth in said petition, and that the said taxes at .the times of the said several assessments became and were and still are a valid and binding lien upon said lands in favor of said county; ” that Chapman and Stryker were the owners in fee of the several tracts by them respectively claimed at the times of the levies, “ and in duty bound to pay said taxes to said county; ” that the said taxes had never been paid, and the “ whole thereof is still due to said county from the said defendant.” Each of these petitions concluded with a prayer for judgment against the defendant for the amount of the taxes, and the enforcement of a lien on the lands for the payment thereof.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.