Supreme Court of Georgia April 11, 1888 (Dannenberg v. Guernsey)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-04-1888

Bleckley, Chief Justice.

The defendants below (the plaintiff in error here) employed a contractor to build certain houses and furnish the materials. The houses were partly built under this contract. The contractor being unable to complete the buildings, was settled with and another person was engaged by the owners to finish the work. Before this, however, the defendant in error had furnished certain materials which were used in the construction of these buildings. The. contractor had been the instrument of purchase, but the material man alleged that he sold to the owners and *550not to the contractor; that he had a verbal order from one of the owners, to furnish whatever supplies of. this character were called for, and in pursuance of that order and not knowing of the existence of the contract between the owners and the contractor, he sold and delivered these materials. He brought his action for the price, and at the trial he established his account. Taking his evidence as true, the plaintiffs in error, the owners, were liable for this debt. The evidence in their behalf, on the other hand, would relieve them from liability, if the jury had given it credit.

1. In the progress of the trial, a receipt in full by the contractor to the owners was offered in evidence and rejected. Its rejection is one of the grounds of the motion for a new trial. Another ground of the motion is, that the court erred in charging the jury that they ought to look to that settlement as a part of the case. The receipt was excluded, — for what reason does not appear; but the settlement itself was in evidence by the testimony of the plaintiffs in error, and by that of the contractor. There was no doubt that the owners had settled with the contractor. The receipt, whether admissible in evidence or not, would therefore throw no new light on the real controversy.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.