Missouri Court of Appeals July 2, 1888 (Turner v. Bondalier)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-07-1888
Ellison, J.
This is an action of replevin. The plaintiff is a minor, and in the statement filed with the justice of the peace before whom the case originated, he asked the appointment of “a next friend.” Such appointment was made, on the day of trial.
On appeal to the circuit court, defendants filed a motion to dismiss the action; pending this motion, plaintiff asked leave to file an amended statement, which was refused, and the motion to dismiss sustained. Judgment wa's then rendered for defendants, and plaintiff ’s motion to set the same aside having been overruled, he appealed to this court.
The objection to the original statement was that it failed to state, as required by sections 2882, 2883, Revised Statutes, that the property had been injured, or how, or in what manner, injured. Also, that the affidavit was made by an agent of the minor plaintiff, and not by his next friend. The affidavit was by “ S. D. Turner, agent for Adolphus Turner, plaintiff.”
I. The statute permits the affidavit to be made by the “plaintiff, his agent, or his attorney.” The question is thus presented, whether an infant plaintiff, without the interposition of a next friend or guardian, can appoint an agent to make affidavit to his statement in replevin. What acts of an infant are void, and what merely voidable, has been a prolific theme for discussion by the courts of this country, and about which there is diversity of opinion. But it is held, with substantial unanimity, that the appointment of an agent by an infant by power of attorney is void. Dexter v. Hall, 15 Wall. 9, 26; Lawrence v. McArter, 10 Ohio, 38; Pyle v. Cravens, 4 Litt. [Ky.] 17; Trueblood v. Trueblood, 8 Ind. 195; Fonda v. VanHome, 15 Wend. 631; Stafford v. Roof, 9 Cowen, 626; Bennett v. Davis, 6 Cowen, 393; *586Knox v. Flack, 22 Pa. St. 337; Armitage v. Widoe, 36 Mich. 124; Semple v. Morrison, 7 Monroe, 298. In Dexter v. Hall, supra, Strong, J.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit