Nebraska Supreme Court January 15, 1888 (Butler v. Kennard)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1888

Reese, Ch. J.

This was an action brought by plaintiff in error against defendant in error, to recover the sum of $150 alleged to be due from him as commissions for negotiating the sale of certain real estate, owned by defendant. The case was tried to a jury, and resulted in a verdict in favor of defendant and a judgment against plaintiff for costs. Plaintiff alleges error, and brings the case into this court for review.

There was a direct conflict in the testimony' upon the trial in the district court. The testimony of plaintiff is to the effect that, at the time stated by him, defendant placed the property in his hands as a real estate agent, to be sold *358for .the sum of $5,000, with a contract for commissions, in case the property was sold; that some time thereafter he showed the property to W. H. Stubblefield, and recommended its purchase upon the ground that the property was cheap and in reality the best bargain which he had to offer. Stubblefield afterwards purchased the property direct from defendant at the same price for which it was offered by plaintiff. Mr. Stubblefield also testified that his attention was called to the property by plaintiff, with the recommendation of the investment, and that the property was soon after purchased of defendant by him, he relying, as he testifies, to some extent, upon the judgment of plaintiff. These facts were denied by defendant, and it is shown, we think quite clearly, that at the time defendant sold the property to Stubblefield he did not know that negotiations had been entered into between plaintiff and Stubblefield.

' Upon the trial the court gave to the jury the following instruction on its own motion, to the giving of which the plaintiff excepted:

“III.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.