Supreme Court of Minnesota August 31, 1888 (First National Bank of St. Paul v. Ames)

Also known as

United States · · · 31-08-1888

VandeRbüRgh, J.

Non-resident witnesses are exempt from the service of civil process upon them while attending to give evidence in causes pending in the courts of this state. Sherman v. Gundlach, 37 Minn. 118, (33 N. W. Rep. 549.) And the principle upon which this exemption rests applies as well to parties as witnesses. In respect to arrest upon civil process, the common-law rule was that suitors, witnesses, and other persons necessarily attending any court were not to be arrested during their actual attendance, which included their necessary coming and returning. 3 Black. Comm. *289; 1 Greenl. Ev. § 316. It was always the policy of the common law that witnesses should be produced for oral examination, and that parties should have full opportunity to be present and heard when their cases are tried. In furtherance of this policy, and the due administration of justice, and as an inducement to secure their attendance, suitors and witnesses from abroad are privileged from liability to suits commenced by summons as well as by capias. Massey v. Colville, 45 N. J. Law, 119; Matthews v. Tufts, 87 N. Y. 568; Merrill v. George, 23 How. Pr. 331; Sanford v. Chase, 3 Cow. 381. And there is no dif*180ference in principle or practice whether the parties are necessarily and in good faith attending the trial of an action in court or an examination before a referee or a master in chancery, as in this instance. 1 Greenl. Ev. § 817.

In the ease at bar it appears that the defendant Adelbert Ames is a non-resident, but is a member of a partnership firm doing business in. this state; that a judgment had been rendered in the district court for Ramsey county in favor of the plaintiff in an action against the partnership firm, in which action this defendant was not served with process, and which judgment, therefore, was enforceable only against the-joint property of all the defendants’ partners, and the separate property of the defendants served.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.