New York Supreme Court February 29, 1888 (Van Sinderen v. Lawrence)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-02-1888

Barrett, J.

The question presented by this demurrer is not precisely the same as that which arose upon the motion for an injunction. It is true, of course, that if no-cause of action was shown, the plaintiff was not entitled to an injunction. The converse does not necessarily follow. Facts' sufficient to entitle the plaintiff to some relief may beset forth, and yet these facts may be sufficient to entitle *413him to the particular injunction prayed for pendente lite. The relief here demanded is in part that the defendant be adjudged to have been fully paid his share in the estate, and that a general release given by him. to the plaintiff, upwards of twenty years ago, be adjudged an effectual and conclusive discharge.

Facts from which if true, this or similar relief should follow, are fully stated, namely, that plaintiff’s accounts as; executor were finally settled in 1867, more than a year after the release was given; that the decree on such settlement included the defendant’s share of the estate ; that such decree has never been questioned or attacked; that the defendant’s present claims are made in bad faith, for the sole purpose of harrassing the plaintiff, delaying the settlement of his accounts as testamentary trustee and hindering the administration of the estate; that the surrogate has no jurisdiction to adjudicate upon the validity of the release ; that in fact the surrogate has so held, and has permitted, the defendant to intervene upon the accounting, notwithstanding the release, upon the ground that he had no such jurisdiction; and that the referee to whom the accounts were sent has actually refused to admit, the release upon the same ground.

These facts certainly entitle the plaintiff to come into a court of equity and there seek repose, by calling on the defendant to disclose and set up the facts upon which, at this late day, he claims invalidity.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.