The Superior Court of the City of New York and Buffalo May 6, 1889 (Moore v. New Jersey Lighterage Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 06-05-1889
Sedgwick, C. J.
The defendant corporation is foreign, having been constituted by the statutes of Hew Jersey. I assume that the plaintiffs are residents of this state, and that the courts of this state have jurisdiction of the action. The appellants make no question as to the jurisdiction. The defendant corporation made a call upon its stockholders generally, including the plaintiffs, of $50 per share. In this call it was declared that any stockholder might assign to the corporation his shares, and that in such case the corporation would issue to him a certificate, for one-half of the number of shares assigned, and the assignment should be in satisfaction of the call. The plaintiffs claimed in this action that such a call was not authorized by law, and was invalid, because the shares of the company had been before the call fully paid for, and were not assessable, and the corporation was not authorized by law to take anything but cash in payment for shares. It, however, appears that, if the plaintiff's were not liable to the .threatened consequences of the call, they would not be injured by other shareholders acceding to the terms of the call. On the papers, the plaintiffs’ shares have been fully paid for, and the call should not be enforced against them. The resolution directing the call specifically threatens to enforce it under its charter; that is, to proceed to forfeit the shares of those stockholders who do not fulfill the demands of the call. The plaintiffs have a right in equity to restrain an attempt to forfeit their shares. When this restraint is made, by the order of the court, they are fully protected against any injury that may come from the enforcement of the case against other shareholders. The order below'should be modified by enjoining the defendants from proceeding to forfeit the plaintiffs’ shares.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit