Supreme Court of Alabama November 15, 1889 (Rutledge v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1889

McCLELLAN, J.

We understand the rule in respect to the admission of evidence, on the part of a defendant- on trial for murder, of previous threats by, or difficulties with, or ill-feeling on the part of the deceased, to be this: that when any phase of the testimony would, if believed, present a case of self-defense, then the accused, using this aspect of the facts adduced as a predicate therefor, may go further, and strengthen it, by showing that the deceased had threatened him, or entertained ill-feeling toward him, or that there had been difficulties between them; and a like doctrine obtains with respect to evidence of the violent character of the slain. Or, to state the principle in a more concrete form, the evidence adduced must have some tendency to establish the constituents of the right to destroy life that life may be preserved- — which are, that the accused was without fault in bringing on the fatal rencounter; that he was in imminent peril, real or reasonably apparent, of loss of life or limb; and that he could not, as the matter presented itself to him, retreat or avoid the combat with safety to himself — before any state of facts exists in the case upon which testimony of character, threats, ill-feeling, &c., of the deceased, could shed any light. The theory of the rule is, that a right to *90kill can never be tbe result of tbe violent, blood-thirsty disposition, revengeful feeling, or threats of the deceased; and hence, until there are facts offered which go in some measure to establish the necessity to strike as the law defines that necessity, such evidence is patently irrelevant. These matters, in other words, are competent to give character to a necessity otherwise shown; and no such necessity being otherwise shown, there is an utter absence of the predicate upon which alone such qualifying evidence should be received. — Prickett v. State, 22 Ala. 39; Quesenberry v. State. 3 S. & P. 308; Franklin v. State, 29 Ala. 14; Roberts v. State, 68 Ala.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.