Missouri Court of Appeals February 4, 1889 (Bain v. Arnold)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-02-1889

Gill, J.

This is an action of replevin brought for the recovery of two horses. The suit originated before a justice of the peace at Kansas City, was tried anew on appeal before the circuit court of Jackson county, where plaintiffs had judgment and defendant appeals to this court.

For the purpose of an understanding of the points decided here, it is sufficient now to say that plaintiffs’ claim is based on an alleged chattel mortgage made to them as mortgagees on July 11, 1885, by one L. M. Hendron in Leavenworth county, Kansas, to secure a debt of one hundred and fifty dollars which said Hendron owed to plaintiffs. When the mortgage was executed plaintiffs and Hendron, the mortgagor, all resided in Leavenworth county, Kansas, and, as already stated, the mortgage was there executed, and it would seem the same was recorded in the office of the register of deeds for said Leavenworth county on July 13, 1885. The mortgage, however, was never acknowledged by said Hendron. Plaintiffs found the horses in the possession of defendant Arnold, at Kansas City, Mo., *633where he, Arnold, then resided. Plaintiff Varney testified that Hendron sold the horses in Kansas City, and that he came here and found them in defendant Arnold’s possession.

At the trial of the cause before the court sitting as a jury, at the close- of plaintiffs’ evidence, the defendant asked the court to declare that under the testimony offered plaintiffs could not recover. The refusal to so declare the law raises the question now here for review.

Did the mortgage, read in evidence, entitle the plaintiffs to the possession of these horses, of course admitting that they made a case in other respects ? We think not.

The effect of this instrument under the Missouri statute would be wholly nugatory except as to the parties thereto.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.