Supreme Court of the United States December 9, 1889, 34 (Young v. Clarendon Township)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-12-1889

Mr. Justice Lamar,

after stating the facts in the foregoing language, delivered the opinion of the court.

"We consider the decisive question in this case, to be that of the laches in. pursuit of the railroad company’s right against the township. In this view the controversy must be narrowed to a single issue: The township, which is the defendant below, and which defends separately, claims that the cause of action accrued- either 13 • or 14 years before this bill was filed —13 years if the conversion pf the bonds by the township and the treasurer be considered the gravamen, and 14 years if it be the governor’s refusal to issue his official certificate; that since the statutes of limitation in Michigan, touching these questions, vary from 6 to 10 years, the cause of action is long since barred at law as to the railroad company; that it is, therefore, barred also in equity , arid lost by laches in its

*346

assertion ;■ and that since the appellant by this bill is prosecuting a demand in the nature of a garnishment, and the railroad company’s .right -is barred both at law and in equity, therefore that of the appellant is also barred. The appellant seeks, to avoid the force of this position by claiming that the bonds had been so far perfected by the dealings between the parties that the railroad company was entitled to have them from the state treasurer; that such being the case, the tort of the township and of the treasurer in converting them could not impair the rights of the company; that, therefore, the company was and is' entitled to waive the tort and sue directly on the bonds, as in the case of lost or stolen bonds; that only a few of such bonds, if delivered, would have been barred at the time of the 'filing of the bill, since most of them were so drawn as to. mature within 10 years of that time; and, finally, that as the company was thus still in possession of an enforcible demand, the appellant could avail himself of it by this bill.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.