New York Court of Appeals April 15, 1890 (Williams v. . Taylor)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-04-1890
*248
Vahtt, J.
The learned General Term based its affirmance of the judgment rendered at the circuit upon the following cases:
L. O. A. & N. Y. R. R. Co.
v.
Mason
(16 N. Y. 451);
Howlcmd
v.
Edmonds
(24 id. 301), and
Tuckerman
v.
Brown
(33 id. 297). One of the learned judges, however, in his concurring opinion, said: “ To hold that the cause of action accrued before the subsequent payments were required to be made, is not consistent with the agreement between the defendant and the company when he subscribed for the stock; * * * but the authorities cited in the opinion -* * * sustain the power of the court to disregard the terms on which the parties made the money payable, and to hold the contract to be one for the absolute payment of so much money at once. They are controlling, although they do violence to the agreement and annul the intention expressed in it.”
The same authorities were relied upon by the counsel for the respondent in his argument before us, and in addition thereto he cited the case of
White
v.
Haight
(16 N. Y. 310).
After a careful examination of these cases we recognize them as well decided, but do not think that they are applicable to the case under consideration.
In
L.
O.,
A. & N. Y. R. R. Co.
v. Mason, the action was brought to recover the amount of
“
the defendant’s subscription to the plaintiff’s articles of asssociation for twenty shares of its capital stock.” The subscription specified “ no condition of time of payment,” but th‘e act under which the plaintiff ivas incorporated provided that the directors might “ require the subscribers to the capital stock to pay the amount by them respectively subscribed in such manner and in such installments as they may deem proper.” (Laws of 1850, chap. 211, §
7.)
This section further pro Added for a forfeiture of all previous payments in case of neglect to pay any installment after personal notice to the subscriber requiring him to pay at a time and place named.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit