Supreme Court of North Carolina February 5, 1890 (Bethea v. . R. R.)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-1890

The killing of the animal was admitted, and there was evidence as to its value. There was also evidence on behalf of the defendant company, tending to show that there was due diligence and no negligence. The evidence of the engineer, which, if accepted by the jury as true, would make a competent defense to the charge of negligent (280) killing, is set out in full in the case on appeal, but "error cannot be assigned and become the subject of review in an omission or neglect to give a specific instruction, even when proper in itself, unless asked, and thus called to the attention of the judge in order that he may rule thereon." S. v. Bailey, 100 N.C. 528, and cases cited. We need not, therefore, advert to the testimony or reproduce it here. The only exceptions presented for our consideration are to the refusal of his Honor to instruct the jury as requested, and to the charge as given. The defendant asked the court to charge the jury as follows: 1. That if the defendant's engine and cars were furnished with all the modern appliances for stopping the cars in emergencies of this kind, and the usual headlight, and the defendant's engine and cars were in charge of a prudent and skillful engineer, who was running his train within the prescribed limit, was at his post, looking forward on the track, and, soon as he discovered the steer on the track by means of his headlight, reversed his engine, blew on brakes, sounded the cattle alarm, and otherwise did all in his power to stop the engine, then the defendant was not guilty of negligence. *Page 234 2. That if the plaintiff permitted his steer to leave home and stray upon the track of the defendant's road, the plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.