New York Supreme Court July 18, 1890 (In re Commissioner of Public Works)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-07-1890

Dykman, J.

This case brings to us three appeals from the report of the commissioners of appraisal appointed to ascertain and determine the compensation to be made by the city of New York to the owners or the persons interested in the real estate sought to be acquired or affected by the proceedings under chapter 490 of the Laws of 1883, to provide new reservoirs, dams, and a new aqueduct, with the appurtenances thereto, for the purpose of supplying the city with an increased supply of pure and wholesome water. The appeals are taken by the executors of George W. Parsons, deceased, owners of a portion of parcels Nos. 608, 610, and 612 of the land described on the map of said aqueduct; by Frank B. Mallory, owner of parcels Nos. 606, 608, part of parcel No. 609, and certain contiguous land not laid out on the map; and by William B. Wadsworth, the owner of other land contiguous to the aqueduct, but not laid down on the map. These three appeals present separate interests; but the claims were all represented by the same counsel, and were tried before the commissioners upon the same evidence, and two of them present the same questions. In the Parsons claim and the Mallory claim, it *706is the insistence of the appellants that the city acquired a fee in the property appropriated, and not an easement, and that, therefore, the commissioners adopted an erroneous principle, and erred in excluding testimony tending to show the damage which the appellants would sustain by the taking of a fee, and consequently awarded them insufficient compensation. The Wadsworth case involves the question of the competency of certain testimony rejected by the commissioners, and all the appeals require an examination of the statute under which the proceedings were instituted and concluded.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.