Supreme Court of Alabama November 15, 1890 (Kansas City, Memphis & Birmingham Railroad v. Smith)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-11-1890
SOMERVILLE, J.
1. The photograph of the trestle and of the wrecked train of cars was shown to have been taken about two hours after the accident occurred, and was verified by the testimony of the photographer as being a correct representation of the locality and scene. It was clearly admissible in evidence, to aid the jury in properly understanding the case.
It is a well understood rule, applied in every day practice in the courts, that diagrams and maps illustrating the scene of a transaction, and the relative location of objects, if proved to be correct, are admissible in evidence in order to enable the jury to understand and apply the proved facts to the particular case. — 3 Brick. Dig. 431, § 366. A plan, picture, or other representation produced by the art of photography, is admissible on like principles, if verified as a true and accurate representation. It is, in fact, but a scientific reproduction of & facsimile of the original object in nature, by a mechanical art which is every day advancing towards perfection. The competency of such evidence was settled in Luke v. Calhoun County, 52 Ala. 115, approving a like ruling in the case of Udderzook v. Commonwealth, 76 Penn. St. 340, where a photograph of a person in life, shown to be a correct picture, was admitted in evidence, for the purpose of aiding in the identification of a deceased person alleged to have been murdered. The case of Ruloff v. People, 45 N. Y. 213, supports the same principle.
In the case of Blair v. Pelham, 118 Mass. 420, which was-an action against a town, to recover damages for injuries caused by a defect in a highway, the defendant was permitted to put in evidence a photograph of the place of the accident, on its verification by the photographer as a true representation. So, in Church v. City of Milwaukee, 31 Wisc. 512, an action for .
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit