Appellate Court of Illinois September 20, 1890 (Ardinger v. Wright)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-09-1890
Pleasants, J.
During the summerand fall of 1882, Wright delivered to Ardinger, Piper & Co., the plaintiffs in error, at their mill in Carrollton, some twelve hundred bushels of wheat. On the 25th of November, the mill with most of its contents was burned, without fault on their part. Wright brought this suit in assumpsit for the value of the wheat he had delivered, and recovered judgment on a verdict for $826.95.
The arrangement for the delivery of the wheat was made between Wright and Piper, and they differ materially as to its terms. Wright testified that he was not to pay anything for storage the first thirty days, but so much per month thereafter, or they were to have the wheat at the market price; that subsequently they changed the arrangement to pay for storage after thirty days, and he paid no storage; that Piper told him, probably in September, they had used the wheat; that two or three days before the fire he went to them and asked a settlement, and they said they would settle at the bank on Saturday ; but they did not settle ; that Piper was at the bank, but he (plaintiff) was not; and that such wheat was worth eighty-seven cents. It was further shown that the wheat was received as Ho. 2 St. Louis grade; that it was put in a bin with other wheat of the same grade ; and that defendants sold and shipped wheat from that bin after the mixture.
Upon this evidence it was claimed for plaintiff, under the rule declared in Lonergan v. Stewart, 55 Ill. 44, and Richardson v. Olmstead, 74 Ill. 213, that the transaction was a sale and not a bailment; that the title and risk were in the defendants and they were liable for the market price.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit