Indiana Supreme Court January 17, 1890, No. 13,660 (Phenix Insurance v. Golden)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-01-1890
Olds, J.
— This is an action by the appellee against the appellant for the value of a barn, which was insured by the appellant company, and was destroyed by fire. Issues were joined and trial had, resulting in a verdict and judgment for appellee.
There was a demurrer filed to the complaint and overruled by the court, and exceptions taken, and the ruling is assigned as error.
The policy of insurance, a copy of which is filed with and made a part of the complaint, contains a condition, that “ if the above-mentioned buildings be or become vacant or un*525occupied, or be used for any other purpose than mentioned in said application, without consent endorsed hereon, this policy shall be null and void.”
There is an averment in the complaint that the plaintiff “ has, upon his part, performed each and every act which, by the terms of said policy, he was required to do.” It is contended by counsel for appellant that the complaint is defective, for the reason that it does not specifically aver that the property was not allowed to become vacant, and that it was •occupied at the time it was burned. If this is a condition precedent, which it was necessary for the plaintiff to aver the performance of to entitle him to recovery, the general averment in the complaint is sufficient. Section 370, E. S. 1881. But it may well be questioned whether or not, in the absence of a general averment, this is not a matter of defence, which must be pleaded by the defendant if a vacancy occurred, which would defeat a recovery. The complaint is sufficient, and the demurrer was properly overruled. American Ins. Co. v. Leonard, 80 Ind. 272; Indiana Ins. Co. v. Capehart, 108 Ind. 270; Commercial Union Assurance Co. v. State, ex rel., 113 Ind. 331.
The defendant answered in four paragraphs : First. A general denial. Second. That plaintiff over-insured his barn, and caused it to be burned to get the insurance money. Third.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit