Supreme Court of Missouri October 15, 1890 (Rush v. Brown)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-10-1890
Barclay, J.
Under our statutes and the uniform construction of them that has for many years prevailed, a married woman cannot be compelled to specifically perform a contract for the sale of her legal estate in land. R. S. 1889, secs. 2396 and 2397; Shroyer v. Nickell, 55 Mo. 264.
■ So well established is this rule, that we are disposed to stop with the briefest announcement of it rather than to hazard obscuring it by elaboration.
II. The prayer of the petition here is for specific performance and general relief. A general demurrer to the petition having been sustained and the case brought here in that shape, the question arises, can plaintiff obtain a reversal because the trial court did not enter judgment against one of the defendants (the husband) for the amount of the purchase money paid as alleged? No prayer for such a recovery is contained in the petition. That is evidently framed with a view to such relief as formerly could have been given only by a court of chancery as distinguished from a court of law.
But it seems to be imagined that any kind of judgment (whether legal or equitable in nature), that any particular facts alleged may warrant, should be given-, under our code of procedure, in such a case, whether asked or not. We do not assent to that view.
One of the purposes of the code is to substitute specific and concise statements of the actual facts of each controversy for the more general declarations of demands formerly in use in courts of law, and the unnecessarily prolix and elaborate pleadings in chancery. The object in view is to have the defendant fully advised in each case of the precise complaint he is called upon to meet.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit