New York Supreme Court October 15, 1891 (Comstock v. Hopkins)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-10-1891
Dwight, P. J.
The action was under the civil damage law to recover for loss and damage resulting to the plaintiff from the death of his son, caused, as alleged, by the intoxication of the latter, produced in part by liquor sold to him by the defendants. The one question of interest in the case is whether the several persons against whom a cause of action exists, under this act, for one and the same injury, are within the principle of the common-law rule which prescribes that satisfaction as to one joint wrong-doer is satisfaction as to all. The rule is abundantly established, as to joint wrong-doers, and rests upon the principle that, as there can be no apportionment of responsibility between them, each must be held responsible, for all, and hence satisfaction by one is satisfaction for all. Bronson v. Fitzhugh, 1 Hill, 186; Woods v. Pangburn, 75 N. Y. 498. The question, above propounded, whether this rule applies to the case of persons equally, and no doubt jointly, liable under the civil damage law, is, so far as we know, a new question in this state. In Massachusetts and Iowa, under similar statutes, it has been *909held that the common-law rule does so apply. Aldrich v. Parnell, 147 Mass. 409, 18 N. E. Rep. 170; Kearney v. Fitzgerald, 43 Iowa, 580. The reasoning of these cases commends itself to our judgment, although we are of the opinion that the conclusion reached does not depend upon the principle that the persons so jointly liable for the injury complained of are joint wrong-doers. It is difficult to see how a man who does only that which he is expressly licensed to do under one statute of the state can be treated, for that act, as a wrong-doer by or under another statute of the state. Certainly what he has done is not in violation of any law of the state, civil or criminal, and we have had occasion to hold that the liability which he has thereby incurred is not in the nature of a penalty. Hall v. Germain, (Sup.) 14 N. Y. Supp. 5.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit