New York Supreme Court October 23, 1891 (Cole v. Roby)

Macomber, J.

This ease has been tried three times. At the first trial, held in September, 1888, before Mr. Justice Daniels and a jury, a verdict for the plaintiff was rendered in the sum of $125. Upon a motion*made for a new trial upon the minutes of the court the verdict was set aside, and a new trial granted.