Indiana Supreme Court May 23, 1891, No. 15,128 (Hormann v. Hartmetz)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-05-1891

Elliott, J.

A demurrer was sustained to the third paragraph of the appellants’ complaint, and upon this ruling is based one of the specifications of error. But as the appellants subsequently filed additional paragraphs, alleging substantially the same facts as those pleaded in the paragraph held bad, and requiring no more evidence to support them, the error, if it was one, was harmless. Where a demurrer is sustained to one paragraph of a complaint, and additional paragraphs are subsequently filed, alleging substantially the same facts, and requiring no more evidence than the one held bad, the ruling on the demurrer is not available. Hunter v. Pfeiffer, 108 Ind. 197, and cases cited. We do not mean to trench upon the long established rule that a plaintiff may state his cause of action in different forms, nor do we do so, for we hold that where there is an amendment the amended pleading is superseded, and that where the paragraphs which remain entitle the plaintiff to give the same evidence as that admissible under the paragraph adjudged bad, and require no greater evidence, an erroneous ruling on the demurrer is not a prejudicial error. Long v. Williams, 74 Ind. 115; City of Elkhart v. Wickwire, 87 Ind. 77. Where, however, a paragraph of a complaint is erroneously adjudged insufficient, and others are held good, the error is not harmless if the paragraphs allowed to stand are substantially different from that held bad, or if those held good impose upon the plaintiff the burden of adducing stronger or greater evidence than would be necessary under the paragraph condemned. If, in other words, the effect of the ruling on demurrer is to make it necessary to introduce more or greater evidence, or to ex-*355elude competent evidence, the error may be prejudicial, but it is otherwise where the ruling on demurrer does not have the effect either to abridge the right of the plaintiff orto increase his burden.

The decision in Summers v. Tarney, 123 Ind.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.