Wisconsin Supreme Court December 15, 1891 (Leisen v. Roberts)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1891

Cole, C. J.

This is a creditors’ bill in aid of an execution. The case really involves no.legal question, but only a question of fact. The plaintiffs are judgment creditors of the defendant Merit E. Roberts. The object of the suit is to reach real estate which was conveyed to the other defendants by one Diarpond, which conveyance, it is alleged, was fraudulent and void as to the creditors of Merit E. Roberts. The defendants Minnie M. and Lottie F. Roberts are his minor daughters. The title to the lands in controversy was in Diamond in September, 1884. He and Merit E. Roberts had had many business transactions with each other before that time, and Roberts was then owing Diamond several thousand dollars for moneys advanced for various purposes. The bona fides of this indebtedness is not seriously questioned. At all events, it is fully estab-*571fished by tbe evidence to a considerable amount. Indeed, it satisfactorily appears that tbe land in question was originally purchased by Diamond, or with money furnished by him, and the title to some of it was conveyed to Roberts by mistake. But there is no room to doubt but Diamond was the real owner of the land, having paid for it with his own money, though there was a verbal understanding that he would convey it to Roberts when the latter paid the purchase money. The lands were originally “ pine chop-pings,” and Roberts cultivated and improved them to some extent as and for a farm, and received what crops were raised from them. Roberts himself was hopelessly insolvent at this time, and had been for years.

In September, 1884, Diamond and Roberts had a settlement of their dealings with each other, and Roberts sold and transferred to Diamond a quantity of cattle, cord-wood, agricultural implements, a livery and saloon building, livery stock, liquors, and other personal property, for the consideration of $8,000, as stated in the bills of sale, to apply on his indebtedness.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.