Ohio Circuit Courts January 15, 1891 (Harrison v. Baldwin)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1891
Stewart, J.
The original petition in this case was filed by the defendant in error asking judgment against the plaintiffs in error upon two promissory notes, each in the following form:
*311“ $2,250.00. ' Columbus, O., Feb’y, 1887.
“On or before 1st October, 1887, I promise to pay to the order of Jacob S. Baldwin twenty-two hundred and fifty dollars, with interest at seven (7) per cent, per annum. Value received.
“ W. P. Harrison,
“Jambs Harrison,
“J. F. Shrontz,
“ Jacob Shrontz.”
The defendants answered, .admitting the execution of the notes, and averring that they were signed by W. P. Harrison as principal, and the others as sureties, and for a first defense alleging that they were executed to the plaintiff and accepted by him to suppress a certain criminal prosecution instituted in the state of Pennsylvania by the plaintiff against W. P. Harrison, and upon plaintiff’s agreement not to prosecute said Harrison, and to dismiss the criminal proceedings. .
And as a second defense, that the notes were wholly without consideration, valuable or otherwise. The reply denies that the notes were without consideration, and avers that they were given in settlement of a civil action which plaintiff had brought against W. P. Harrison; and avers that if any part of the consideration was the settlement of a criminal prosecution, the notes were delivered in Pennsylvania, and by the laws of that state such settlement was lawful. Upon the trial a verdict was found in favor of the plaintiff, and we are asked to reverse the judgment rendered therein, because the verdict was contrary to law and the weight of the evidence, and for errors in the charge.
An examination of the bill of exceptions shows that there is no conflict about any matters of substance, ■ and that the testimony adduced establishes :
1. That these notes were delivered in Pennsylvania, upon a valuable consideration.
*3122.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit