Ohio Circuit Courts September 15, 1891 (Martin v. Falconer)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1891

Shauck, J.

The plaintiffs seek the judgment of this court touching the proper distribution of the estate in their hands. Their intestate was the relict of John G. Deshler, who died January 8th, 1878, intestate, leaving no children or their legal representatives. Upon his death the estate in controversy passed to the intestate of the plaintiffs, pursuant to the provisions of the second and fourth sections of the act regulating descents and distributions. S. & S. 304 and 397. She died without issue February 12,1878, and this property thereupon passed, one-half to her brother and the, legal representatives of a deceased brother, and one-half to the brothers and sisters of John G. Deshler or their personal representatives, pursuant to the provisions of the act of April 11, 1877, supplementary to the act regulating descents and the distribution of personal estates. 74 Ohio L. 81. '

The answer of Louise D. Stembel and others alleges all the facts necessary to entitle them to share in the moiety which passed to the brothers and sisters of John G. Deshler, if his brothers and sisters of the half blood may take with his brothers and sisters of the whole blood. The question indicated is raised by demurrer to their answer.

*585Although some lexographers, having in mind only the usual relation, have defined brothers and sisters to be offspring of the same parents, other authoritative definitions, the common use of the words by the educated, and judicial decisions, make it clear that brothers and sisters, though of the half blood only, are brothers and sisters; and our statute of descents makes provision for “ brothers and sisters of the half blood.” We cannot say that the defendants are excluded from participation by the language of the supplementary act, considered out of its relation to the other statutory provisions upon the subject.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.