U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Washington April 15, 1891 (Hamilton v. The Walla Walla)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1891

Knowles, J.

In this case there was a trial in the district court of the first district-of Washington Territory, and now stands on appeal in this court from the judgment against the defendant in the former court. The plaintiff was at the time he received the injury complained of what is commonly called a “longshore-man.” He belonged to an association of longshore-men, who were employed through their president, Thomas Gafney, to assist in loading the Walla Walla. It does not appear with which officer of the steamer Gafney made the contract of employment. It is certain the plaintiff was in the employ of some one who had the authority to engage him in the work of placing the freight of the steamer on board. The evidence established that the injury which the plaintiff received while in the employ of the steamer was on account of the negligence of the second mate of the Walia Walla, one Fitz-Morris. Some of the evidence would indicate that the injury was occasioned through what, might be called wanton negligence. His conduct, according to these witnesses, indicated a thorough disregard of the rights of the plaintiff. The conduct of the first officer of the ship, on being informed of the injury, was such as could not have been dictated by any' kindly spirit, and indicated a disregard of common human sympathy. These considerations would impel a court, if possible under legal rules, to afford the plaintiff some redress for his injuries.

The first point urged on the part of the defendant is that the complaint was so defective as not to allow any proof against the defendant thereunder. The negligence is alleged to be that of the second mate, Fitz-Morris. There are no allegations of any duties of this officer in regard to the work of loading the ship that would make it liable for his act. He is alleged to have been second mate.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.