Supreme Court of North Carolina February 5, 1892 (State v. . Shields)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-02-1892
Davis, J.:
The defendant was charged with an assault and battery on one Samuel P. Carden, with a deadly weapon, to-wit, an axe. The defendant and prosecutor were at the house of Frank Carden, a brother of the prosecutor. It was in evidence that Sam. Carden was in the yard sharpening an axe, when the defendant asked ,Frank Carden’s wife for a gun, which she refused to let him have, her husband being absent; whereupon the defendant used opprobrious and insulting language to her, calculated to provoke a breach of the peace, and went into the house to get the gun, after being forbidden; that afterwards he went to the prosecutor and seized the axe in his hands, and in the struggle to get possession of it struck him over the head, and also broke his collar-bone.
It was also in evidence that the prosecutor had raised the axe to strike the defendant, and that each had hold of the-axe and was endeavoring to get possession of it when the
*498
blows were struck; that John Shields, a son of the defendant, testified that the prosecutor said, “If you go in the house I will mash your brains out with the axe.” There was much other conflicting testimony, some of it tending to show that the prosecutor had assaulted the defendant, and that there was an affray.
No special instructions were asked of the Court, but counsel for the defendant, in his address to the jury, laid much stress upon the alleged fact that the prosecutor had assaulted the defendant with an axe, and defendant used only sufficient force to disarm the prosecutor. His Honor charged the jury,among other things': “In this case all the witnesses having stated that a blow was struck, by which the defendant, in the difficult}’', broke the shoulder-blade of the prosecuting witness, tiie defendant cannot justify such' blow, unless he was acting in self-defence. If he used no.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit