New York Supreme Court October 21, 1892 (Oughterson v. Clark)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-10-1892

Macomber, J.

This action was brought upon a promissory note given by the defendant to one Lucy J. Clark, and by the latter transferred to the plaintiff, in the sum of $278, and alleged to have been made in the year 1878. The defenses set up in the answer are: (1) That the note was made in 1875, instead of 1878; (2) that the date was changed after the note was executed and delivered to Lucy J. Clark; (3) the statute of limitations. Upon all of these questions the jury found a verdict in favor of the plaintiff. No motion for a* new trial having been made, either upon the minutes of the court or at special term, no review of the facts arising from such trial can enter into our consideration of the case. Unless, therefore, some legal error was committed upon the trial, prejudicial to the defendant, the judgment appealed from must be affirmed.

The only question on this appeal admitting of debate arises out of the plea of the statute of limitations. When this action was begun, the statute had apparently run against this note. With this issue presented by the answer, (there being no written promise or acknowledgment .by the defendant in writing reviving the note,) the burden of proof rested upon the plaintiff to show that, notwithstanding the lapse of more than six years from its maturity, the note had been kept alive by the payment of some part of the principal or interest. When produced in court it bore the following indorsement: “Received on the within, interest, $5.00, January 1, 1885.” This was in the handwriting of the then holder of the note. If the payment purporting to have been made by this indorsement was actually made at the time indicated, the note was clearly saved from the operation of the statute; otherwise not.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.