New York Court of Common Pleas February 1, 1892 (Douglass v. Leonard)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-02-1892

Bischoff, J.

Plaintiff sued to recover the fair and reasonable value of services, as an expert accountant, alleged to have been rendered and performed by him, at the request of William H. Leonard, in and about the preparation of the accounts of said Leonard, George W. Parsons, and Mrs. Almira Reed, as joint executors of and trustees under the last will and testament of Ebenezer Reed, deceased. The answer denied the employment of the plaintiff by the defendant, the performance of the services, and the value thereof; and the trial of the issues thus created resulted in a verdict for the *592plaintiff for $1,500, the full amount claimed, being at the rate of $20 per day for 75 days, with interest, upon which judgment was duly entered in his favor. At the close of the trial the defendant moved for a new trial upon the minutes, and upon the several grounds specified in section 999 of the Code of Civil Procedure, which motion was denied, and from the order entered upon that denial, as well as from the judgment, the defendant appealed to the general term of the court below, where the judgment only was reversed and a new trial granted; and from that order of reversal the plaintiff appealed to this court. The fact, therefore, that the order of the trial justice denying defendant’s motion for a new trial remained undisturbed, confines us to the consideration of the validity of defendant’s exceptions as authority for reversal of the judgment.

Upon the close of the introduction of plaintiff’s direct evidence, defendant’s counsel moved to dismiss the complaint upon the grounds that plaintiff had failed to establish his employment by the defendant individually; that there was a variance between the pleadings and the proof, in that the latter established an employment by the defendant jointly with Parsons and Mrs. Reed; and that defendant and Mrs. Reed, as survivors of the three joint contractors, should have been joined as defendants in this action.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.