Supreme Court of Colorado September 15, 1892 (Morey v. Harvey)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-09-1892

Chief Justice Hayt

delivered the opinion of the court.

The foregoing summary of the pleadings will show that thé suit is based upon a single cause of action. This cause of action is stated differently in the several counts, undoubtedly for the purpose of providing against the varied aspects which the proof might assume upon trial. In the first count the plaintiff seeks to recover upon the quantum meruit; in the second he pleads an express agreement, by the terms of which he was to receive the sum of $5,000 for his services as a broker in making a sale of defendant’s property. At the trial, the district court held that the plaintiff was only entitled to recover on the quantum meruit, and so instructed the jury. This action on the part of the court is the principal *43ground of complaint upon which a reversal of the judgment is sought.

■ The correctness of the ruling of the court below depends upon the evidence. An examination of this will show the employment of plaintiff by defendant to sell the property described in the pleadings ; that plaintiff, acting under such contract, procured a purchaser for this property upon terms that were acceptable to the owner, and that the sale was actually consummated with such purchaser. The only question in dispute, therefore, is as to the commission to which plaintiff is entitled. Plaintiff claims that he is entitled to judgment for $5,000, while defendant contends that the amount was properly fixed upon the quantum meruit.

It is in evidence that Harvey authorized Morey to sell the quarry for not less than $15,000 in cash, and that it was orally agreed between them that Morey should have all that could be obtain ed for the property above this amount. Morey procured purchasers for the property in the persons of Russell Bros. & Bills at the stipulated price of $20,000. The payment of this amount was arranged satisfactorily to all the parties, and the sale completed upon this basis.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.