Appellate Court of Illinois December 12, 1892 (McDole v. Simmons)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-12-1892
Mb. Justice Cabtweight.
This is a suit by appellee against appellant to recover moneys alleged to be due under the provisions of a lease, by virtue of which appellee occupied appellant’s farm, and also for board of one Robert Jones, and for work of a team and repairing a bridge at a fish pond on the farm. By the terms of the lease appellant was to have three-fourths and appellee one-fourth of the hay, straw, grain, corn and other crops, and of the increase of stock mentioned in the lease raised on the farm, in growth, value and numbers. The bill of particulars filed in the case embraced many charges and was made up mainly of items of one-fourth of hay, straw and grain, and of increase in growth, value and numbers of stock, which it was claimed had not been paid to appellee, as provided in the lease. Appellant disputed these claims and contended that he had suffered much damage by the neglect, waste and bad management of appellee as tenant. Appellee’s bill of particulars amounted to $593.66, and on a trial the jury returned a verdict in his favor for $461.14, on which judgment was entered. An examination of the evidence satisfies us that even if the jury concluded that all the claims of appellant for damages were unfounded, they allowed to appellee upon his charges more than the evidence would justify. It will be sufficient to refer to enough such charges, not sustained by the evidence, as will demonstrate this fact. Among the claims of which evidence was given, was one of SI for use of one cow and increase in growth and value of calf. This charge was founded on the provision of the lease that appellant was to put twenty cows on the farm for the joint use of the parties. The lease further provided for bearing losses by the death of any of the number, but did not make appellee an insurer that the cows would stay on the farm, or that the number would be kept good if one should be lost.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit