Indiana Court of Appeals January 8, 1892, No. 441 (City of New Albany v. Ray)
Also known as
United States · · · 08-01-1892
Crumpacker, J. —
Ray sued the city of New Albany for wrongfully collecting a large body of surface water upon a public alley, by artificial means, without providing any out*322let theréfor, whereby the plaintiff’s premises were overflowed and damaged.
There are three paragraphs of complaint, to each of which a demurrer was' filed and overruled. An answer was filed and the cause was tried by a jury. A verdict was returned in favor of the plaintiff, upon which judgment was rendered.
The first question for decision arises upon the demurrer to the first paragraph of complaint.
It is insisted that this paragraph does not show that the city was engaged in any municipal undertaking from which the alleged injury resulted. The averments upon this subject are as follows: “ That said defendant, without right, wrongfully and unlawfully dug and excavated alongside of her said house in said public alley, a hole sixty feet long, twenty feet wide and two feet deep, and caused to be drained therein the water falling and flowing upon said alley, without providing any outlet therefor, thereby causing said hole to fill up with water and overflow into plaintiff’s said cellar, etc.”
By express statutory provision municipal corporations have exclusive control of streets and alleys, and the establishment and maintenance of drains and sewers. It appears from the allegations quoted above that the city excavated a basin upon a public alley, into which it drained such alley, and provided no outlet for the water; and this, we think, was sufficient to show that work was done in the execution of a corporate power. The power of a city to improve streets or construct drains does not depend upon the formal adoption by the common council of any plan or system for such improvement or drainage.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit