U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern Ohio June 2, 1892, No. 4,339 (Chemical Nat. Bank v. Armstrong)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-06-1892
Sage, District Judge,
(after stating the facts as above.) Conceding that the transaction of the $300,000 loan was fraudulent as between E. L. Harper and the Fidelity Bank, and that he appropriated the entire proceeds to his individual use, the claim of the Chemical Bank, which dealt in good faith in the transaction, and was innocent of any knowledge or participation in the fraud, is not affected thereby. The negotiation of the loan was within the authority of Harper, as vice president ■of the Fidelity Bank, and, if he used that authority fraudulently for his own advantage, the bank that enabled him to commit the fraud must suffer the consequences, and not the bank that made the loan and *803advanced the money, under the representation and in the belief that it was conducting a lair, legitimate business transaction with the Fidelity Bank.
The only questions to be decided are—
(1) Upon what sum shall dividends be computed?
(2) Shall the Chemical Bank be charged with the $25,000 Wilshire-Lewis note, duo Juno 28, 1887, as if it had been collected?
(8) Shall interest be allowed the Chemical Bank upon the sum which may be found duo to it for dividends?
In Lewis v. U. S., 92 U. S. 618, 623, the principle of equity that a creditor holding collaterals is not bound to apply them before enforcing his direct remedies against the debtor is recognized as settled. The authorities in support of the principle as stated are numerous. So far as it relates to the collaterals yet remaining in the possession of the Chemical Bank, there is no difficulty about its application in this ease. The contention arises upon the question whether the sums that have been paid to and received by the Chemical Bank on account of collateral notes pledged to it to secure the loan shall be first credited, and dividends paid on the residue; or, on the other hand, dividends shall be paid upon the entire amount as if those payments had not been made, and then the payments applied.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit