Supreme Court of the United States December 19, 1892, 70 (National Tube Works Co. v. Ballou)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-12-1892
Mr. Justice Blatchfokd,
after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court.
' In his opinion in the' case, Judge Wallace states that he sustains the demurrer on the authority of his decisions in
Claflin
v. McDermott, 20 Blatchford, 522, 12 Fed. Rep. 375; and
Walser
v. Seligman, 21 Blatchford, 130, 13 Fed. Rep. 415; that he feels free to say that he doubts whether those cases did not adopt too technical a view of the right of a creditor, whose judgment has been obtained against his debtor at the place of the latter’s domicil, and whose execution has been issued there and returned unsatisfied, to maintain a creditor’s bill in a court of another State; and that he ihay be permitted to express the hope that the present case- may be taken to this court for review.
In
Claflin
v.
McDermott, supra,
it was held, that a creditors bill, founded on a judgment recovered against a debtor in a state court in California, would not lie in a Circuit Court of the United States in New York, to set aside a fraudulent transfer of personal property made by the debtor in California, by means of collusive judgments and sales under executions issued thereon, no judgment having been obtained or execution issued in such Circuit Court or in_any state court of New York. The- case of
Tarbell
v.
Griggs,
3 Paige, 207, was cited as au
*523
thority, where the Court of Chancery of the State of New York refused jurisdiction -of a creditor’s bill filed, to obtain satisfaction of a judgment rendered in the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of New York, and upon which an execution had been returned unsatisfied, the judgment being treated as á foreign judgment and as standing on the same footing with the judgments of a court of another State. The principle invoked was, that the plaintiff’s remedy at law had not been exhausted by the issuing and return of an execution on a foreign judgment; and
McElmoyle
v. Cohen, 13 Pet. 312, was referred to as authority.
In
Walser
v.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit