Texas Supreme Court December 7, 1893, No. 67. (Herf and Dittmar v. James)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-12-1893

STAYTON, Chief Justice.

Plaintiffs make application for writ of mandamus to compel the judges of the Court of Civil Appeals for the, Fourth Supreme Judicial District to certify to this court for decision a case in which there was dissent as to the qualification of one of the judges of that court.

Before parties will be cited to show cause why such relief should notj be granted, the petition will be looked to, in order to ascertain whether

*231

it states a cause in which this court has jurisdiction, either original or appellate.

The petition in this case simply shows that plaintiff recovered a judgment in the District Court for Bexar County, against the county, for $600 as damages for opening a public road over land owned by them, and that upon appeal to the Court of Civil Appeals that judgment was reversed and judgment rendered in their favor for only $180, with interest from a date mentioned.

The inference from the petition is, that the judgment was rendered by the District Court in a condemnation proceeding, originating in the County Commissioners Court and appealed to the District Court.

There is no averment showing a case over which a County Court would not have either original or appellate jurisdiction; and in the absence of such averments, it can not be presumed that the District Court rendered the judgment in the exercise of its exclusive original jurisdiction.

If this court has power to grant the relief asked, it is under its appellate jurisdiction.

Plaintiffs base their right on the statute, which prescribes, that

“

When any one of said Civil Courts of Appeals shall in any cause or proceeding render a decision in which any one of the judges therein sitting shall dissent as to any conclusions of law material to the decision of the case, said judge shall enter the grounds of his dissent of record, and the said Court of Civil Appeals shall, upon motion of the party to the cause, or on its own motion, certify the point or points of dissent to the Supreme Court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.