California Supreme Court December 30, 1893, No. 15132 (Schmidt v. Brieg)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-12-1893

Paterson, J.

This is an action for an injunction, and to recover damages for an infringement of plaintiffs’ trademark and labels.

The facts found by the court below are substantially as follows: In the year 1887, plaintiffs commenced to manufacture and sell a new and valuable medicinal compound or beverage, and adopted and used in con- *676and Iron.” By reason of the superior character of the medicinal constituents employed in the manufacture of the beverage or compound it became widely known and highly esteemed by the trade, and identified and distinguished by dealers and consumers under the designation of “ Sarsaparilla and Iron.” This name was not at that time in use, or known as a designation of any similar article of manufacture on sale. For the purpose of identifying the beverage as being of their manufacture, and to distinguish it from other articles of a similar nature, plaintiffs have affixed to the bottles containing the same their own labels, devices and trademark, specimens of which are attached to the complaint herein. The article has become widely known, to the public and to buyers and consumers thereof as the beverage manufactured and sold by the plaintiffs not only through the name “ Sarsaparilla and Iron,” but through said labels, and up to the time of the infringement, hereinafter referred to, large sales and great profits had been made by the plaintiffs. The defendants, since the month of December, 1888, willfully disregarding the rights of the plaintiffs, and with the intention to divert to themselves the business of the plaintiffs and the profits and gains thereof, have fraudulently prepared, sold, and now continue to manufacture and sell throughout the state of California, an article or beverage in imitation of the plaintiffs’ beverage, having the same taste, flavor and appearance as plaintiffs’ article, with the intent to deceive and defraud the public and to injure and defraud the plaintiffs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.