South Dakota Supreme Court August 15, 1893 (Rosenbaum v. Foss)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-08-1893
Corson, J.
On January 10, 1889, one Charles W. Seefield being the owner of a certain steam flouring mill, engine house, engine, boilers, etc., situated upon lands leased from the railway company in the town of Arlington, in Kingsbury county, executed a bill of sale for the same to Rosenbaum Bros., plaintiffs herein, for the consideration of $25,000, and under which said plaintiffs took possession of said property on January 19, 1889. Prior to the execution and delivery of said bill of Sale by said Seefield to the Rosenbaums, he executed and delivered to Foss, Strong & Co., defendants herein, two mortgages to secure the payment of about $15,000, which mortgages included, among other property, the steam flouring mill, engine, engine house, boilers,' etc., included in the bill of sale above described. In April, 1889, the Rosenbaums commenced this action to set aside, annul and cancel the two prior mortgages as against them, on the grounds that neither the original mortgages nor duly authenticated copies of the same were filed in the office of the register of deeds of Kingsbury county, and that the Rosenbaums had no actual notice of the same, but that purported copies of said mortgages were on file in said office that cast a cloud upon the title and interest of said Rosenbaums to the property described in their bill of sale. An answer was filed by the defendants, and the cause was referred to a referee, who found the facts, which the court below adopted as its own find1 ings, except one not material to a decision in this case. Numerous exceptions were taken to the findings, all of which were overruled. A motion for a new trial was made and denied *190and judgment rendered for the plaintiffs, from which the defendants appealed.
The findings of facts are exceedingly voluminous, extending over some twenty pages of the printed abstract, but it will only be necessary for the purposes of this decision to refer to a few of them.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit