Oregon Supreme Court April 24, 1893 (State v. Henderson)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-04-1893
Mr. Justice Bean
delivered the opinion of the court.
The defendant was indicted, tried, and convicted of murder in the first degree in killing one Cyrus Suter, by stabbing him with a pocket knife. The evidence tended to show that the deceased and the defendant had for some *102two or three hours immediately prior to the homicide been playing cards and drinking liquor in a saloon at Ganby ; that some dispute had arisen over the game, and defendant had threatened to quit playing, but, at the solicitation of the deceased, continued in the game, and that .just prior to the killing the dispute or quarrel was renewed, when the defendant again arose from the table and said he would not play any more, that Suter had been trying to run over him all day. The deceased, who was a much larger and stronger man than the defendant, then got up from the table, approached and took hold of the defendant,— whether in a peaceable or violent manner the witnesses are not agreed,— when, as claimed by the state, defendant stabbed him with an ordinary pocket knife, whereupon the deceased seized a chair and attempted to strike him with it, but was prevented from doing so by a bystander. The defendant and deceased then engaged in a hand to hand conflict, and defendant was thrown and held down on the floor by the deceased until the bystanders interfered. At some time during this affray the fatal wound was inflicted, hut just at what .time is not clear.
1. The court, in its instructions to the jury, in defining the crime of murder in the first degree, said: “The law also requires, in order to constitute murder in the first degree, that the design should be formed in cool blood, and not hastily on the occasion, and unless it is so formed in cool blood there can be no murder in the first degree; but by cool blood is not meant that a party must be in a wholly unexcited and philosophical state of mind.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit