Supreme Court of Iowa October 9, 1893 (Schier v. Dankwardt)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-10-1893

Rothrock, J.

It appears,’from the record presented on this appeal, that the plaintiff was the owner of a judgment against J acob C. Wertz. On the fourth day of January, 1890, he caused the defendant, Dankwardt, *751to be garnished on execution as a supposed debtor of Wertz. At that time, Dankwardt held a chattel mortgage on all of the personal property of Wertz to secure the payment of a promissory note for one thousand, three hundred and twenty dollars, and had taken possession thereof, and advertised the same for sale on the seventh day of January, 1890. The mortgaged property consisted of a threshing machine, horses and cattle, and farming utensils, and such other property as is in common use by farmers. On the day appointed for the sale, Dankwardt appeared on Wertz’s.premises, and the sale was held with Dandwardt as auctioneer, and he purchased most of the property. In the issue as made up on the answer of the garnishee, it was claimed by the plaintiff that the sale was irregular, fraudulent and invalid. This was denied by the garnishee. It is conceded that the garnishee acted as auctioneer at the sale, and that he purchased nearly all of the property. The sale was well attended, and some of the persons present were there with the intention of purchasing property. It appears from the evidence of some of the witnesses that there was dissatisfaction expressed with the manner in which the sale was conducted. It fairly appears that the property was not collected together, as is usually done at a public sale. The most valuable article of property was a threshing'machine. The separator belonging to the machine was some two or three miles away from the place of sale. Witnesses testified that the animals were driven up when they wanted to sell them, and very few of them could be examined until off eredfor sale. One witness testified that he “saw a black bull sold. He was not brought up with the rest of the stock, and he went through the pasture.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.