Michigan Supreme Court December 22, 1893 (Breig v. Chicago & West Michigan Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-1893

Montgomery, J.

This is an action of negligence. Plaintiff was in the employ of defendant in its foundry and car shops. The declaration avers that plaintiff’s duties ■consisted in attending and operating an emery wheel, which wheel was used for the purpose of polishing and sharpening tools used in said shop and for gumming saws; that while the plaintiff was gumming a saw, using the emery wheel for that purpose, the wheel broke, and he was injured by some of the pieces flying into his face, cutting his lips, and doing other -serious injury. The negligence charged against the defendant was—

1. That the wheel was not properly encased. .

2. That an inferior kind of stone was used; that the stone used was not filled with copper wire, or wire of any kind.

3. That the wheel was run at an improper rate of ■speed.

4. That the stone furnished to be used in said wheel would not properly fit in such manner that it could be made secure.

5. That there was no rest or guard connected with said wheel.

The declaration also averred that plaintiff had called the attention of the foreman of the shop to the fact that the shaft was too loose, and he had promised to remedy the defect. The circuit judge charged the jury as follows:

“If an employé, knowing that a machine is unsafe, works upon it, consents to work upon it, has preknowledge, understands its condition, understands that it is in an unsafe, condition, and knowingly continues to work with it, he assumes the risks that are liable to follow. If *224lie does that without finding any fault, he assumes them the more; and he also assumes them even if he does find fault, unless, as a result of his finding fault, some promise is made to him by his employer to repair or correct, and there is a failure to do it within the time promised, or within a reasonable time.”

This is, in the abstract, a correct statement of law. Sjogren v. Hall, 53 Mich. 274; Prentiss v. Manufacturing Co., 63 Id. 478; Kean v. Rolling Mills, 66 Id. 277; Melzer v.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.