Supreme Court of Rhode Island December 13, 1894 (Citizens Savings Bank v. Mitchell)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-12-1894

Matteson, C. J.

Gifts

causa mortis

require for tlieir support the clearest and most satisfactory proof, No doubt or suspicion should he left in the mind of

*740

the court concerning the essential facts. In

Grey

v.

Grey,

47 N. Y. 552, 556, it is said, “the clearest proof on the part of the claimant is required. It (the gift) must be established beyond suspicion.” Again, in

Cosnahan

v.

Grice,

15 Moore, P. C. 215, 223, it is said, “Cases of this kind demand the strictest scrutiny. So many opportunities, and such strong temptations, present themselves to unscrupulous persons to pretend these death-bed donations, that there is always danger of having an entirely fabricated case set up. And, without any imputation of fraudulent contrivance, it is so easy to mistake the meaning of persons languishing in a mortal illness, and by a slight change of words, to convert their expressions of intended benefit into an actual gift of property, that no case of this description ought to prevail, unless it is supported by evidence of the clearest and most unequivocal character.” And see also

Conklin

v.

Conklin,

20 Hun, 280;

Lewis

v.

Merritt,

42 Hun, 161, 163;

Shirley

v.

Whitehead,

1 Ired. Eq. 130, 133.

We do not think that the evidence in this case on the part of the claimant meets the requirement of the rule. The gift is testified to by the claimant, Sarah E. Williams, who is the daughter of the deceased, and by a witness named Bowlin, a boarder of Miss Williams. They testify that on Sunday, July 30, 1893, the day before the decease of Mrs. Douglass, she told Miss Williams to get her satchel and take the hooks which were contained in it (among which was the bank book issued by the complainant, the Citizens Savings Bank,) and bring them to her; that Miss Williams did so and handed the books to her mother ; that Mrs. Douglass passed them hack to Miss Williams with the statement that they were hers; that she should keep them ; they were hers forever. A witness, Elizabeth A.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.