Supreme Court of Florida January 15, 1894 (Jacksonville, Tampa & Key West Railway Co. v. Griffin)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-01-1894
Raítey, C. J. :
This action was begun on March 11th, 1890. In view of its similarity to that of the same company as. appellant vs. Lockwood,' ante, page 573, with which it has been considered, hardly more than an application of the principles there determined will be necessary.
I. The demurrer is to the amended declaration, but-the first ground of demurrer as set forth is that the declaration in the first count does not allege that the' plaintiff either by himself or his agent was in possession of the premises at the time of the alleged trespass. This ground of demurrer goes, of course, only to the-first count. The argument here in behalf of the ap*604pellant is: That the plaintiff, the appellee, alleges that he was in possession of the premises on January 20th, 1884, and that he is still in possession, and the trespass is alleged to have been committed March 15th, 1887, but there is in the declaration nothing to show that at the time of the trespass the plaintiff was in possession, and that an inference that he was in possession then can not be fairly drawn from the language used, as the plaintiff might have sold the premises after 1884, remained out of possession during the time of the alleged trespass, and then re-purchased just prior to the institution of this suit. This ground of demurrer is confined to want of possession, and does not extend to want of title to the freehold or fee.
In our judgment there is no merit in this point. The material trespass alleged to have been committed on March 15th, 1887, was one constituting a permanent and necessary injury to the market value of the plaintiff’s fee in the land, and he is entitled to recover for such injury to his fee, whether he was in possession at the time or not. It is unnecessary to enter into any discussion of the right to recover for the entire damage in such cases; the question is fully considered and must be regarded as finally settled by the decision in the case of Jacksonville, T. & K. W. Ry. Co. vs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit